LLC formation

I chose to file myself after comparing formation service prices

Started by quietstorm_88 • November 16, 2026 • 11 replies
quietstorm_88

Spent a few weeks comparing LLC formation services. The monthly packages add up fast with registered agent fees and 'compliance' upsells. I ended up filing directly with my state's website. Took about an hour and cost me the $125 filing fee plus a $50 registered agent I found on my own. The services quote you $0 formation but then lock you into $30/month for agents and other stuff. Not saying it's always wrong, but for a simple single-member LLC I couldn't justify it.

kettle_boi

Did the same thing last year. Once you realize the state portal is just a form, it's pretty straightforward. Good call.

Marlene_in_Ohio

I've been going back and forth on this. Which registered agent did you go with for $50? Cheapest I've found is around $90/year and that's if I pay two years upfront. Also did you have to file anything separate for an EIN or does that come later?

gravelpit

OP's math checks out if your state doesn't require publication.New York is a different beast. LLC filing is cheap but you're paying hundreds for newspaper publication unless you qualify for the exemption. People comparing prices often miss that.

smokestack_light

The $0 formation thing is usually just a teaser. You're right that the registered agent fee is where they make their money. I used a service for the first year because I didn't want to think about it, then switched to a cheaper agent when it renewed.

kettle_boi

@Marlene_in_Ohio EIN you get directly from the IRS, it's free and instant if you apply online during business hours. No need to pay anyone for that.

Marlene_in_Ohio

Thanks kettle_boi. I might just do it myself then. The $50 agent still seems low but maybe I'm looking at the wrong providers.

terminal_cascade

I used a formation service and honestly I don't regret it. I was working 60-hour weeks at my job and the convenience was worth the extra $100 or so. Not everyone has time to read state instructions and troubleshoot a portal that looks like it was built in 1998. Different priorities, I guess.

gravelpit

Thats fair. But the comparison should really be about total cost over two or three years, not just year one. The service packages get expensive at renewal because the agent fee and any compliance tools kick in. If you're organized enough to file yourself once, you're probably organized enough to handle the annual report reminders.

smokestack_light

One thing worth mentioning—some states won't accept a third-party registered agent unless they have a physical address in the state. I had a cheaper mail-forwarding agent get rejected. Had to switch to a local one.

terminal_cascade

Also your own address is usually fine as the registered agent if you work from home. That's the part people overlook. You don't legally need a separate agent company unless you want privacy or you're not at that address.

quietstorm_88

@Marlene_in_Ohio Sorry for the late reply. I went with a small local bookkeeping office that does agent services as a side thing. It was $50 because I called and asked. Might not scale but worth checking locally. And yeah, EIN directly from IRS, free.


Post a reply

🚀 Start Your Free LLC