So I picked up a 5,000-count lot of mostly basketball and football cards from a local estate sale. My plan is to break it into smaller lots and run them on Whatnot. I've sold on eBay for years but never done live auctions. Anyone here have experience with Whatnot specifically for bulk cards? Wondering if it's worth the effort vs just listing as singles or team lots on eBay. The collection has a lot of 90s stuff, some stars but mostly commons.
I bought a collection of trading cards specifically for Whatnot auctions
Whatnot can work for bulk but the fees and shipping eat into margins fast. You need to factor in the 8-10% commission plus payment processing. For low-end cards, you're better off doing team lots or repacks. Live breaks of cheap cards can be fun but don't expect big profits.
How much did you pay for the lot? That changes everything. If you got it for a few hundred bucks, you have room to experiment. If you paid thousands, you might be stuck.
Paid $400. Mostly 1990-1995 stuff, some Jordans and Emmitt Smiths but nothing graded. I figured even at a dime per card average I could double up if I'm patient, though.
Honestly, for 90s commons you're looking at a lot of work for little return. Whatnot buyers want hits or nostalgia. You might do better sorting out the stars, selling those as singles, and dumping the rest as a giant lot. Live aution for commons is a tough sell unless you bundle them into myster packs.
Mystery packs are a gray area on Whatnot. Some sellers do them but you have to be careful about how you describe them. If you're vague, you'll get complaints. If you're too specific, nobody buys. I'd stick to clear team lots or Player lots.
I've run about 40 Whatnot shows, mostly mid-tier singles and some sealed. The platform is best for live interaction and and impulse buys. For a collection like yours, I'd suggest doing a few shows where you showcase the better cards and then offer the rest as add-on lots. But you need to build an audience first, which takes time.
Building an audience is the hard part. You can't just list and expect people to show up. You need to promote on social media, do giveaways, be consistent. If you're not ready to commit to weekly shows, Whatnot might not be worth it.
I appreciate the reality check. I was thinking of doing a couple of test shows with just the better cards and see how it goes. Maybe $50 starting bids on small lots. If it flops, I'll just list the rest on eBay as bulk.
That's a reasonable plan. Just don't get discouraged if the first show has low turnout. It takes a while. Also, make sure you have good lighting and a decent camera setup. People won't bid if they can't see the cards clearly.
One more thing: shipping. Whatnot's shipping labels can be tricky for bulk lots. You might want to offer flat rate shipping or bundle multiple wins. Buyers expect combined shipping, and if you don't offer it, you'll lose bids. Factor that into your pricing.
Also check the sold comps on Whatnot before you set expectations. Some categories are oversaturated. 90s basketball is popular but there's a lot of it out there. You might need to niche down to a specific player or team to stand out.