LLC dispute

I almost abandoned my business name over an out-of-state LLC

Started by CopperKettle77 • November 19, 2026 • 9 replies
CopperKettle77

I run a tiny handmade soap company in Oregon. Last month I got a cease-and-desist from a company in Florida with almost the same name. They registered an LLC there years ago but don't even sell soap. I panicked and nearly rebranded everything, labels, website, Etsy shop. Then a friend said an out-of-state LLC doesn't automatically give them nationwide rights. But now I'm second-guessing whether I should have just changed the name to avoid the headache. Anyone dealt with this?

TumbleweedSally

That's rough. I had something similar with my candle business. A guy in Texas had the same name registered as an LLC but never used it commercially. I ended up keeping my name after a lawyer told me an LLC filing alone doesn't establish trademark rights. But it cost me a few hundred bucks to get that advice. Have you talked to anyone yet?

PixelPioneer

Not a lawyer, but I've been through this. The key is who used the name first in commerce, not who filed paperwork first. If you've been selling under that name and they haven't, you might have common law rights. But it's messy across state lines. Document everything—sales records, social media dates, receipts.

MossyRock

Did they actually send it through a lawyer or just a scary letter? Sometimes these are just bullying tactics. I'd check if they have any actual sales under that name. If not, they might not have a leg to stand on.

CopperKettle77

It was from a lawyer, but a pretty generic letter. They claimed 'common law rights' but didn't provide any evidence of sales. I looked them up—their website is basically a placeholder. I'm leainng toward ignoring it, but my partner is nervous.

TumbleweedSally

A placeholder website doesn't mean much. They could be selling on Amazon or elsewhere. But if they haven't used it in commerce commerce, their claim is weak. Still, fighting it could drain your time. Maybe respond asking for proof of use? That might shut them up.

PixelPioneer

That's a good mov. Also check your state's secretary of state database—if they're not registered to do business in Oregon, that's another point. But honestly, even if you're right, the cost of a legal fight might outweigh rebranding. It sucks but sometimes the practical choice is to change the name and move on.

DustyTrail

I wouldn't ignore it completely. Send a polite response asking for documentation of their common law rights—like dated sales records. If they can't provide it, you've called their bluff. But keep it professional. And don't admit any wrongdoing.

MossyRock

DustyTrail has a point. Also, consider filing for a trademark yourself if you've been using it. That could give you leverage. But that's a longer game. For now, a firm but polite letter might do the trick.

CopperKettle77

Thanks,everyone. I'm going to draft a response asking for proof. If they can't show real sales, I'll keep the name. If they push back, I'll weigh the cost. Appreciate the sanity check.


Post a reply

🚀 Start Your Free LLC