Hiring

How much does it cost to hire your first employee?

Started by velvet_pepper • November 17, 2026 • 15 replies
velvet_pepper

I run a tiny online shop (just me) doing about $120k/year. Thinking about bringing on a part-time helper for packing and customer emails. What's the real cost beyond wages? I'm scared of hidden fees and paperwork. Give me the ugly truth.

rusty_banjo

Payroll taxes are the big one. Budget 15-30% on top of wages depending on where you are. Plus workers comp insurance, which can be a few hundred a year for a low-risk desk job. And don't forget the cost of your own time to do payroll and onboarding.

mossy_keyboard

Following. I'm in the same boat. My accountant quoted me $500 just to set up payroll. Is that normal?

rusty_banjo

That's not crazy for a setup fee if they handle registration and first filings. But you can do it yourself with Gusto for like $40/month plus fees. Depends how much you value your sanity.

grumpy_llama

Don't forget the pizza party budget. Morale is expensive.

soggy_cereal

I hired my first employee last year. The biggest surprise was the jump in my insurance premiums. My general liability went up because I had an employee on the premises. Also, I didn't factor in the cost of training time – I basically paid someone to shadow me for two weeks while my own productivity tanked.

velvet_pepper

Training time is a good point. I was only thinking about the hourly wage. How long until they were actually useful?

soggy_cereal

For packing and emails? Maybe a month before I trusted them to not ship the wrong thing. But it depends on the person. The first hire was slow. The secknd one picked it up in a week.

pixelated_pirate

Also consider the cost of turnover. If you hire wrong, you're back to square one plus unemployment claims. I'd say budget an extra 10% for 'oops' money.

rusty_banjo

And don't forget mandatory posters in the break room. That's like $20. But the real hidden cost is the emotional labor of managing someone. It's not just money.

mossy_keyboard

Emotional labor? Try telling that to my bank account.

grumpy_llama

If you're in the US, check if your state has a new hire reporting requirement. Miss that and you get fined. Happened to a friend.

velvet_pepper

Thanks all. Sounds like I should budget about 20-25% on top of wages plus a few hundred for setup. And maybe wait until I can afford to lose a month of my own productivity. Appreciate the reality check.

soggy_cereal

One more thing: if you're hiring part-time, make sure you understand the overtime rules in your area. Some states have daily overtime. Don't assume it's just over 40 hours.

pixelated_pirate

Also, you might want to look into a PEO if you're nervous. They handle payroll and benefits for a fee. Might be overkill for one part-timer though.

mossy_keyboard

Let us know what you decide. I'm still on the fence.


Post a reply

🚀 Start Your Free LLC