I run a small handyman biz as an LLC (taxed as S-corp). Thinking of starting a separate pressure washing LLC. My accountant says just make it a division of the existing one. But a friend says parent/subsidiary is cleaner for liability. Anyone actually done this? I'm not trying to overcomplicate my life.
Does it make sense to put a new LLC under an existing one?
Your friend isn't wrong but 'cleaner for liability' is doing a lot of work there. A parent LLC doesn't magically shield you if both are just you. If the pressure washing side injures someone and it's under the same LLC, the handyman assets are exposed. Separate LLCs = separate asset pools. That That's real. But you'll pay a second annual fee and file two returns.
How different are the two businesses? If pressure washing is literally a guy with a wand and some soap, a division is fine. If you're buying a truck, a trailer, and chemicals, separate entities start making more sense.
Probably one truck, trailer, surface cleaner. Not huge. But I do have a couple employees on the handyman side that I'd rather not have tangled up with it.
If you have employees, that changes thinngs. An employee doing pressure washing under the handyman LLC could drag the whole company into a claim. Parent/sub just means two LLCs with one owning the other. It's not that complicated, it's just more paperwork.
I looked into this and the extra account fees, registered agent, and tax prep ate the savings. For a one-truck operation it wasn't worth it until we hit about 250k revenue. YMMV.
Put the pressure washer under a holding company under a trust under a shell corp in Delaware. That's what the internet says, anyway. Then spend all your profits on the accountant.
Honestly if you're not sure, start it as a division and revisit in a year. You can always spin it out later. The opposite is messier. Also ask your insurance agent before your accountant, they'll tell you how they'd rate the risk.
Didn't think to ask the insurance person. That's probably the move. Appreciate the answers, even the sarcastic one.