LLC

Can I register a Montana LLC while living in California?

Started by mountain_brew_42 • November 21, 2026 • 12 replies
mountain_brew_42

I'm a California resident and I want to start a small online retail business. I've heard that registering an LLC in Montana can have tax advantages, but I'm not sure if I can do that while living in California. Does anyone have experience with this? What are the legal requirements and potential pitfalls?

PragmaticOwl

Yes, you can legally form a Montana LLC as a non-resident. Montana doesn't require you to live there to be the owner. But California will likely treat it as a foreign LLC doing business in California if you're running the business from your home. That means you'll have to register it with the California Secretary of State and pay the $800 annual franchise tax. The Montana tax savings might be minimal after that, though.

GoldenGateChick

I looked into this for my consulting biz. You also need a Montana registered agent, which costs around $100-200 a year. And if you're the only member, Montana's annual report fee is $20. But California's FTB is aggressive about nexus. If you're managing the LLC from CA, theey'll say it's doing business in CA. So you'd file in both states. Probably not worth it unless you have a physical presence in Montana.

rogue_planner

What's the actual benefit you're hoping for? Montana has no sales tax, but if you're selling online, you likely already handle sales tax via economic nexus rules. Income tax? If the LLC is pass-through, California taxes your personal income regardless of where the LLC is registered. So unless you're planning to move to Montana eventually, the tax advantage is mostly a myth.

MontanaLocal

I live in Montana and see a lot of out-of-state LLCs. Just a heads-up: some counties require a physical address for for certain licenses. A registered agent address works for formation, but if you need a business license, you might hit a wall. Also, the Montana Secretary of State website has a clear guide on foreign LLCs. Worth reading before you pay any service.

grizzly_78

I did this exact thing three years ago. Formed a Montana LLC while living in San Diego. It was fine for the first year, but then California sent me a notice for the $800 franchise tax plus penalties because I hadn't registered as a foreign LLC. I edned up dissolving the Montana LLC and starting a California LLC. The extra paperwork and double fees ate any savings. Not recommended unless you have a real reason to be in Montana

SkepticalSam

Common misconception. The only real benefit is privacy (Montana doesn't publish member names) and sometimes asset protection. But California can still pierce the veil if you're not careful. And if you're doing business in CA, you must registuer there. So you're paying two sets of fees. For a small online retail biz, an LLC in your home state is simpler.

CaliGirlExplores

Wait, are you planning to have a physical location in Montana? If not, you're just creating extra work. I looked into this for my Etsy shop and my CPA said don't bother. The California FTB will come after you for the franchise tax anyway. Better to use a California LLC or even a sole prop until you grow.

NomadPreneur

Actually, if you have no physical presence in California (no office, no employees, no inventory), you might argue you're not not doing business there. But if you're running it from your home, that's a physical presence. The rules are tricky. Consult a lawyer who knows both states. Don't rely on forum advice for this.

PragmaticOwl

NomadPreneur has a point. But even then, California's economic nexus rules for income tax are based on sales, not physical presence. If you're selling to CA customers, you might still be on the hook. The Franchise Tax Board is not known for being lenient.

rogue_planner

What kind of online retail? If it's drop-shipping, your inventory never touches CA, but your management does. Still likely nexuss. I'd focus on your business model first. The Montana LLC is a distraction.

GoldenGateChick

One more thing: if you form a Montana LLC and then register it in California as a foreign LLC, you'll pay the $800 CA franchise tax plus the $20 MT annual report. The total annual cost is higher than just a CA LLC. The only way it makes sense is if you plan to move to Montana or have significant Montana-source income. Otherwise, skip it.

SkepticalSam

Also, the California Secretary of State charges a $100 filing fee for foeign LLC registration. So you're looking at $800 + $100 + $20 + registered agent fees. Versus $800 for a CA LLC (plus $100 filing). The math doesn't work for small businesses.


Post a reply

🚀 Start Your Free LLC