I run a small audio repair shop. A local musician I've done work for before came in with a proposal: he wants to trade a vintage 1970s analog synth and a couple of old pedals for a 15% share of profits for the next two years. The gear is in decent shape but not museum quality. I'm torn. On one hand, I could sell the gear outright and keep all future profits. On the other, having him as a regular customer and getting some cool vintage stuff for the shop window might bring in business. Has anyone done a profit-share barter like this? What should I watch out for?
A musician offered vintage gear in exchange for company profits
What's the estimated value of the gear vers us what 15% of your profits over two years might be? If you can't pin that down, it's not a real trade, it's a gamble.
I wouldn't touch a profit share without a written agreement that defines 'profits' very clearly. Net or gross? Before or after your own salary? That kind of thing gets messy fast.
How well do you know this musician? If he's flaky, you might end up with gear you can't sell and a headache every month when he asks for his cut.
I've known him for about three years. He's reliable, pays on time, but he's also not the most organized guy. I'm leaning toward a one-time trade for a flat fee instead of a profit share. The vintage synth is a Roland something, and the pedals are Boss from the 80s. I could probably get $800-1000 for the lot on Reverb. But the idea of him bringing in his friends to buy strings and get repairs is tempting.
If you're already established and have steady profit, giving away 15% for two years could cost you way more than the gear is worth. Unless your profit is tiny, that's a bad deal.
Could you do a smaller percentage, like 5%, or cap the total payout at a certain amount? That way you're not giving up too much if you have a good year
To add to my earlier point, make sure the agreement specifies what happens if you sell the gear before the two yeaars are up. Does he still get a cut of profits from the sale? And who pays for repairs or maintenance on the gear while it's in your shop?
Honestly, I'd just buy the gear from him outright if you want it, or pass. Profit-sharing with a customer sounds like it could complicate your relationship. Next thing you know, he's asking to see your books every quarter.
What dusty_corner said. If you're doing okay, 15% is a lot. Maybe offer him store credit instead? He gets gear gear or repairs, you keep your profits.
Thanks for for the input. I think store credit is a good middle ground. I'll propose that and see if he bites. If not, I'll probably just pass on the whole thing. Appreciate the reality check.