Barter Deals

A musician offered vintage gear in exchange for company profits

Started by copperkettle_99 • November 15, 2026 • 10 replies
copperkettle_99

I run a small audio repair shop. A local musician I've done work for before came in with a proposal: he wants to trade a vintage 1970s analog synth and a couple of old pedals for a 15% share of profits for the next two years. The gear is in decent shape but not museum quality. I'm torn. On one hand, I could sell the gear outright and keep all future profits. On the other, having him as a regular customer and getting some cool vintage stuff for the shop window might bring in business. Has anyone done a profit-share barter like this? What should I watch out for?

hollowtree_88

What's the estimated value of the gear vers us what 15% of your profits over two years might be? If you can't pin that down, it's not a real trade, it's a gamble.

quietstorm_42

I wouldn't touch a profit share without a written agreement that defines 'profits' very clearly. Net or gross? Before or after your own salary? That kind of thing gets messy fast.

juniper_wren

How well do you know this musician? If he's flaky, you might end up with gear you can't sell and a headache every month when he asks for his cut.

copperkettle_99

I've known him for about three years. He's reliable, pays on time, but he's also not the most organized guy. I'm leaning toward a one-time trade for a flat fee instead of a profit share. The vintage synth is a Roland something, and the pedals are Boss from the 80s. I could probably get $800-1000 for the lot on Reverb. But the idea of him bringing in his friends to buy strings and get repairs is tempting.

dusty_corner

If you're already established and have steady profit, giving away 15% for two years could cost you way more than the gear is worth. Unless your profit is tiny, that's a bad deal.

ramble_on_17

Could you do a smaller percentage, like 5%, or cap the total payout at a certain amount? That way you're not giving up too much if you have a good year

quietstorm_42

To add to my earlier point, make sure the agreement specifies what happens if you sell the gear before the two yeaars are up. Does he still get a cut of profits from the sale? And who pays for repairs or maintenance on the gear while it's in your shop?

stonewall_jenny

Honestly, I'd just buy the gear from him outright if you want it, or pass. Profit-sharing with a customer sounds like it could complicate your relationship. Next thing you know, he's asking to see your books every quarter.

juniper_wren

What dusty_corner said. If you're doing okay, 15% is a lot. Maybe offer him store credit instead? He gets gear gear or repairs, you keep your profits.

copperkettle_99

Thanks for for the input. I think store credit is a good middle ground. I'll propose that and see if he bites. If not, I'll probably just pass on the whole thing. Appreciate the reality check.


Post a reply

🚀 Start Your Free LLC